Home
Gillian [userpic]

Audiobook from iTunes.

April 1st, 2008 (11:04 am)

I finally gave in and bought an audiobook from iTunes. I've been toying with the idea for a while, especially since I started walking a lot for exercise. I also take long bus rides on the weekends, and I do get a little bored just listening to music.

I was considering a Master & Commander book - but they are very dear, $35+ so I held off. Then last night I had the brilliant idea of searching for Naomi Novik's Temeraire novels, and was thrilled to see all four. I chose the Unabridged - (I never did see the point of an Abridged novel) version of His Majesty's Dragon, the first in the series, and I shelled out the $26.99 - still very dear, but more affordable I thought.

I'd listened to the minute & a half sample, and quite liked the cultured English voice of the reader - David Thorn (although oddly I was expecting a woman's voice) .

Sadly the snippet they posted had no audio - I was pretty horrified when I downloaded it and began listening to find that it was a dramatic reading, with the reader attemptng various voice and accents. 

Oh. My. God. The voice he chose for Temeraire... I can hardly describe how bad it is. Feeble and childish, more suited to a character like Dobby from Harry Potter than a dragon. I was trying not to let it spoil the rest of the book for me when I had the second shock.

The bloody thing is Abridged. I mean, I know this book. I've read it so many times I could pick straight away when a passage was altered or shortened or just plain left out.

I've contacted iTunes, told them the thing was mislabelled - I want my money book or the actual Unabridged version of the book that I paid for. I'll wait and see what they have to say.

It's quite soured me on the whole audiobooks idea. Maybe I was spoiled by Stephen Fry reading the HP books - he made no attempt at accents or performance, just read the books in his beautiful voice. 

Has anyone else had any experiences with Audiobooks?

Comments

Posted by: Amireal ([info]amireal)
Posted at: April 1st, 2008 01:09 am (UTC)

If you find you really get into audio books, I'd suggest a subscription to audible.com, you get 1 free book a month (I often buy the most expensive book I can with 1 credit thus really getting something like %30 - %50 percent off) plus you get a decent discount being a club member, PLUS it's a format that works on iPods and OTHER MP3 players that are also audible devices. *G*

Posted by: Amireal ([info]amireal)
Posted at: April 1st, 2008 01:10 am (UTC)
Not the prince you're looking for!

p.s. you do sort of have to look into who is reading them, the Princess Diaries (which I use as 'light reading' and are pretty good) are all read by Anne Hathaway, the woman who played the main cahracter in the movies. Helps muchly.

BTW audible can be setup to automatically import into itunes so you don't have to worry it being hard to deal with or something.

Posted by: Luthien ([info]luthien)
Posted at: April 1st, 2008 11:40 am (UTC)
Cats: doubleblink by icon_goddess

The only thing to be careful of with audible.com is that if you're outside the US a fairly large proportion of their catalogue is not available to you. Found that out the hard way - bastards!

Posted by: Bernice ([info]iibnf)
Posted at: April 1st, 2008 03:16 am (UTC)

I listened to Mitch Pileggi read an X Files audio book and it was so excrutiatingly boring it nearly put me off audio books for life. He was worse than a robot!

Posted by: ChelleToo ([info]chelletoo)
Posted at: April 1st, 2008 04:31 am (UTC)
Easter Chick

I listen to the Jim Dale Harry Potter audio books. They are excellent. Jim does different voices for each character but they work. He also does the voice over for "Pushing Daisies". I also listen to Bruce Campbell read his own novels.

This first thing I look for in an audio book is whether it is unabridged and then who is doing the reading.

Posted by: sealie ([info]jimandblair)
Posted at: April 1st, 2008 08:05 am (UTC)

The first audio book I listened to was Harry Dresden #1 read by James Marsters, then Stephen Fry's Harry Potter. They've been the yard stick by which I've measured all audio books since. Voice to me is of primary importance. I have a couple of my favourite books and if the reader's monotone or goes too far into the unnatural (often squeaky) voices, I can't listen. Although when I heard Jonathon Frakes pretending to be Deanna Troi I almost herniated myself laughing.

Posted by: Luthien ([info]luthien)
Posted at: April 1st, 2008 11:50 am (UTC)

The reader is the crucial thing with any audio book; it can really make or break it. I've listened to quite a few. There are degrees of "dramatic" reading. I wouldn't call Stephen Fry's performance of the HP books undramatic, in the sense that he does make a distinction in how he delivers dialogue from different characters, though something like Nigel Planer's readings of Pratchett's Discworld novels, which I've been listening to lately, tend to be a lot more of a dramatic performance. Then again, the material lends itself to that sort of thing and he's the right sort of reader for it.

Among my favourite audio books are Roy Dotrice's readings of several of George RR Martin's 'A Song of Ice and Fire' books. They're fabulous.

7 Read Comments